New Providence was the strongest market in this corner of Union County: 110% of list price town-wide across 122 sales. The number that carries it is the four-bedroom tier. A $1,201,000 median, 38 sales, 113% of list, thirteen days on market. Thirteen days is not a market, it is a queue. And unlike most boroughs, the tiers here agree with the headline rather than hiding behind it: nothing in New Providence sold below 105% of list, at any price point.
Data sourced from the Garden State MLS (GSMLS), August 2025 through July 2026.
Every tier in the borough beat asking price. Here is where the money and the competition actually were.
| Bedrooms | Sales | Median sale | Avg days | Sale-to-list |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 3 | $525,000 | 21 | 105% |
| 2 | 8 | $624,750 | 18 | 109% |
| 3 | 45 | $992,000 | 29 | 110% |
| 4 | 38 | $1,201,000 | 13 | 113% |
| 5+ | 28 | $1,674,500 | 27 | 108% |
| Town total | 122 | $1,109,000 | 23 | 110% |
Houses at $1,201,000. 38 sales. Closed at 113% of list in thirteen days. That is the story of New Providence. Thirteen days means the house was listed, shown over a weekend, and awarded; 113% means the winning buyer paid roughly $138,000 over the asking price on a $1.2 million listing. There is no ambiguity in a figure like that. If you are shopping this borough at that price point, you are not negotiating, you are competing.
Just below it, houses at $992,000 made up 45 sales. The largest single group in the borough, and closed at 110% of list, but took twenty-nine days to do it. That combination is worth pausing on: the same ten-point premium over ask, more than twice the market time. The under-$1M stock here takes longer to find its buyer, but when it does, that buyer pays just as far above list. Slower is not softer.
At the top, homes at $1,674,500. 28 sales. Closed at 108% of list in twenty-seven days. In most neighbouring towns the top tier is where the sale-to-list ratio collapses toward or below 100%. In New Providence it does not. Eight points over asking on the borough’s most expensive quarter of the market is genuinely unusual, and it is the clearest evidence that the 110% headline is not a statistical artefact.
The eight sales at $624,750 rounded the year out at 109% of list in eighteen days. A small tier, but consistent with everything above it. The three one-bedroom sales are printed for completeness only; three transactions cannot support a conclusion.
Assume you will pay over asking, and split your strategy by price band. Around $1,201,000 you need to be ready before you see the house: thirteen days average means the property is effectively gone in its first weekend, and 113% means the winning offer is roughly ten to thirteen points above list, typically with clean terms. Around $992,000 you have slightly more room to think. Twenty-nine days is nearly a month, but the eventual price is still 110% of list, so do not mistake the extra time for a discount. Above $1.6 million, the pace is calmer at twenty-seven days but the premium is still eight points. There is no price band in this borough where a buyer holds the advantage.
This is as strong a seller’s position as exists in the county, but the right tactic differs by tier. If your house sits near $1.2 million, price it to the market rather than above it and let the thirteen-day dynamic do the work. A correctly priced four-bedroom here generates competing offers, and competing offers are what produced 113%. If your house is nearer $992,000, expect a month rather than a fortnight and do not panic in week three; that tier still finished ten points over list. Above $1.6 million, 108% and twenty-seven days is the realistic frame. Excellent by any standard, and better than most surrounding towns achieve at their top end.
With a borough median of $1,109,000, a house under a million dollars in New Providence is very often an older, smaller or dated property, and two very different things can happen to it. Lot size decides which. On a smaller lot, a home needing significant work gets no premium. It sits, and it sells at or below asking, whatever the 110% and 113% tiers around it are doing. The buyer is an owner-occupier costing out a kitchen, a roof, windows and a bathroom, and every dollar of that comes off your price.
On half an acre or more, that same house is a completely different asset. It becomes a builder target, and the buyer is paying for land rather than for the house. Owners in that position are routinely priced off tired-house comparables. An agent pulls the three most dated recent sales nearby, prices to them, and the land value is never claimed. In a borough where the four-bedroom median is $1,201,000 and new construction trades well above it, the value of a buildable lot is not a rounding error. It is also a warning to buyers: if you are shopping under $1M on a large New Providence lot, you are bidding against builders, not just against other families.
Ryan Horvath is an agent with Prominent Properties Sotheby’s International Realty and a former licensed New Jersey general contractor. Having a vendor network that will put a real number on the work, and whether a New Providence lot carries builder value or only house value. Is the difference between those two outcomes.
New Providence’s $1,109,000 median at 110% of list is the strongest sale-to-list figure among its immediate neighbours. Berkeley Heights, adjoining to the south-west on the same rail branch, posted $903,757 at 106%. Roughly $205,000 cheaper with a market four points less aggressive, and the most direct cheaper alternative for a buyer priced out here. Springfield, further east, is cheaper again at $674,000 and 103%, a genuinely different price tier for buyers whose budget stops well short of a million.
Above it sits Summit, one stop up the line, at a $1,608,000 median and 108% of list. About $500,000 more expensive, and, notably, running a slightly weaker sale-to-list ratio than New Providence. Westfield, further south, came in at $1,352,500 and 106%. Both of those towns cost more per house; neither generated more competition per house. That is the case for New Providence in a sentence: it is not the most expensive town on this line, but over the last twelve months it was the hardest one to buy in.
New Providence has two NJ Transit stations of its own. New Providence and Murray Hill. Both on the Gladstone Branch of the Morris & Essex Lines. Trains run east through Summit, where riders change for many New York Penn Station services, with some direct trains during peak periods; Gladstone Branch service also runs to Hoboken, where PATH connects to lower Manhattan and midtown. Having two stations in a borough this size is unusual, and it means a large share of the housing stock is within a short walk or a very short drive of a platform.
New Providence operates its own K-12 school district, the New Providence School District, serving the borough alone. Students progress through the borough’s elementary schools to New Providence Middle School and New Providence High School. There is no regional district and no send-receive arrangement at the high school level. The borough educates its own students from kindergarten through graduation, which is a meaningful part of why a town of this size sustains a $1,109,000 median.
New Providence is a compact borough of roughly three and a half square miles on the Passaic River side of the Watchung ridge, and it is effectively two places. The borough centre sits along Springfield Avenue, with a modest walkable commercial stretch near the main station. The Murray Hill section, at the borough’s western end, has its own station, its own postal identity and a long-standing corporate research presence.
The housing stock is predominantly post-war: colonials, capes, ranches and split-levels built through the 1950s and 1960s as the borough filled in, on lots that run comfortable rather than grand. Layered over that is a steady stream of newer construction and substantial expansions, which is what the $1,201,000 four-bedroom median and the $1,674,500 top tier are largely made of. The mix of dated original stock and heavily renovated or rebuilt houses on the same streets is the defining feature of the market here, and the reason condition, not bedroom count, drives price.
The median sale price in New Providence was $1,109,000 across 122 residential sales recorded in the Garden State MLS between August 2025 and July 2026. By bedroom count the medians were $624,750 for two bedrooms, $992,000 for three, $1,201,000 for four, and $1,674,500 for five or more.
A seller’s market at every price point, and the strongest one in this part of Union County. The borough closed at 110% of list town-wide, and no bedroom tier finished below 105%. The most competitive segment by a clear margin is the four-bedroom band at a $1,201,000 median, which sold at 113% of list in thirteen days. Buyers should not expect negotiating room anywhere in this market.
The average sale price was $1,208,582 against a median of $1,109,000. About $100,000 higher. The average is pulled upward by the twenty-eight sales at $1,674,500 and above, while the median simply reports the middle transaction of the 122 sales. For a buyer trying to understand what a typical New Providence house costs, the median is the more useful number.
Twenty-three days on average across the borough, but the spread by price band is wide. The $1,201,000 four-bedroom tier averaged thirteen days; the $992,000 three-bedroom tier averaged twenty-nine, and the top tier twenty-seven. Both the fastest and the slowest of those segments still closed at 110% of list or better, so market time here reflects how quickly the right buyer appears, not how much they are willing to pay.
The median sale in New Providence was $1,109,000, which sits above $1,000,000, so a typical sale here now triggers New Jersey’s Graduated Percent Fee, formerly the “mansion tax.” Since July 10, 2025 it is paid by the seller rather than the buyer, at 1% in this range, charged on the entire sale price. Because the rate steps up at fixed thresholds, a sale crossing one by a small margin can cost more than it gains. See the New Jersey mansion tax seller’s guide for the brackets and where the thresholds fall.
Market data derived from Garden State MLS (GSMLS), August 2025 through July 2026. Statistics reflect residential sales and are not a guarantee of future results.
Buying, selling, or just curious what the numbers say. Call me.