Madison Borough recorded just 132 residential sales over the twelve months through July 2026. The lowest volume of any market Ryan Horvath profiles in depth. Those homes sold at a median of $1,300,000, at 106% of list price, in an average of 22 days. Madison’s defining characteristic is not price or speed. It is scarcity: fewer than three homes trade here in a typical week. Ryan is a Prominent Properties Sotheby’s International Realty agent and a former licensed general contractor in New Jersey.
Data sourced from the Garden State MLS (GSMLS), August 2025 through July 2026.
The 106% ratio is the easy part to plan for. On a $1,300,000 median that is roughly $78,000 over asking. Competitive, but a number you can budget toward rather than guess at. Madison is not a market where you need to escalate blindly.
The hard part is 132. Across an entire year, that is the whole borough. Every price point, every street, every condition. Subtract everything outside your budget, your bedroom count, and your tolerance for renovation, and the set of houses you would actually buy may be a dozen or fewer per year. The practical consequence is that in Madison, patience costs more than money does. Buyers who wait for a perfect match often watch a season pass without one appearing. The winning approach here is usually to define which compromises you can live with before you start, so that when something viable lists, you can act inside the 22-day window rather than debating.
Low inventory is your leverage. In a borough that produces 132 sales a year, a well-presented house is not competing against fifteen similar listings. It may be competing against two. That scarcity is what carries the 106% premium and the 22-day pace.
It also means timing matters more here than in a deeper market. Listing when three comparable homes happen to be active is a materially different transaction than listing when none are. In a market this small, a two-week shift in launch date can change your outcome, and that is a conversation worth having before the sign goes up.
Madison sits in a tight cluster of Morris County towns with similar temperaments. Chatham Borough, immediately adjacent, closed at 110% of list on a $1,450,000 median. Slightly pricier and slightly more competitive. Morris Township ran an identical 106% ratio at a $956,000 median, which makes it the most direct step down in price without a change in market character. Summit, one town east in Union County, closed at 108% on a $1,608,000 median.
Compared with Essex County, Madison is calm. Montclair closed at 121% of list and Maplewood at 114%, both on lower medians than Madison’s. A buyer moving from Essex to Morris typically finds the bidding less punishing here even as the price rises. The constraint shifts from competition to availability.
Madison is served by NJ Transit’s Morris & Essex Lines, with Midtown Direct service from Madison station to New York Penn Station. The station sits at the edge of the downtown, so a significant portion of the borough is within walking distance of both the train and the commercial district. An unusual combination in Morris County and part of why demand outstrips the borough’s small housing supply.
The Madison Public School District serves the borough, with Madison High School as the district high school. Because Madison is a small, single-district borough of roughly four square miles, there is no meaningful school-district variation from one neighborhood to another. A simplification buyers coming from split or regional districts often appreciate.
Madison is known as the Rose City, a name inherited from its era as a center of commercial rose growing. Drew University sits within the borough, and the Museum of Early Trades & Crafts occupies the former public library on Main Street. The downtown along Main Street and Waverly Place is compact and genuinely walkable, with restaurants and independent retail concentrated within a few blocks of the train station.
Ryan is a former licensed New Jersey general contractor and construction project manager, not a contractor for hire, but your agent, who knows construction and the people who do it.
The value is not in spotting a problem before the inspector does. Get a proper inspection either way. It is in what happens once the report lands, which is where the money in a transaction actually moves. Ryan’s vendor network will walk a property inside the inspection window and put a real written estimate on paper.
If you are selling, that means answering a round-number credit demand with a genuine quote from a contractor prepared to do the job. Typically far below what was asked, and it holds because it is real. If you are buying, it means credit requests built on itemised figures that survive line-by-line scrutiny, rather than round numbers that invite a counter.
On his exclusive listings, Ryan identifies the work a home needs to reach the market and pays for it himself. Staging, minor repairs, deep cleaning, landscaping, junk removal, storage and a professional pre-inspection. Knowing what a buyer’s inspector will find before the house is listed is how you keep credits from being negotiated out of your sale price later.
After closing, the same vendors do the work. And something eventually pops up in every house, whatever you bought and however new it is, so his clients keep a former construction professional on call, for a read on which projects actually return money and a gut-check on the contractor’s proposal in front of them.
The median residential sale price in Madison Borough was $1,300,000 across 132 sales recorded in GSMLS between August 2025 and July 2026.
Madison homes sold in an average of 22 days over that period, closing at 106% of list price.
Madison is a borough of roughly four square miles with a correspondingly small housing stock. At 132 sales a year, roughly two to three homes change hands in a typical week across the entire town.
A seller’s market, driven more by limited supply than by bidding intensity. At 106% of list, premiums are moderate; the pressure on buyers comes from how little becomes available.
Morris Township closed at a $956,000 median with the same 106% sale-to-list ratio, making it the closest comparable market at a lower price point. Chatham Borough runs higher, at a $1,450,000 median and 110% of list.
The median sale in Madison was $1,300,000, which sits above $1,000,000, so a typical sale here now triggers New Jersey’s Graduated Percent Fee, formerly the “mansion tax.” Since July 10, 2025 it is paid by the seller rather than the buyer, at 1% in this range, charged on the entire sale price. Because the rate steps up at fixed thresholds, a sale crossing one by a small margin can cost more than it gains. See the New Jersey mansion tax seller’s guide for the brackets and where the thresholds fall.
Market data derived from Garden State MLS (GSMLS), August 2025 through July 2026. Statistics reflect residential sales and are not a guarantee of future results.
Buying, selling, or just curious what the numbers say. Call me.